Free checklist · No signup

Website Redesign Checklist

The old site looks dated, but it still brings in leads, and nobody wants to be the one who breaks that. This seven-step checklist runs a redesign from a measured baseline to a launch you can compare against it, with a redirect map that protects rankings and a client review on the real build.

Use it on this page, copy it as Markdown, or import the .docx into Google Docs or Notion.

Free checklist · 7 steps · Works with any stack

Website redesign checklist

0 / 7 steps

Fill in once, used throughout the template

  1. 1

    Measure the old site first

    Project lead, with analytics or SEO support

    You cannot prove the new site is better without a before.

    GoalA dated record of how the current site performs, and a list of every URL it has.

    • Record sessions, conversions, top landing pages and the queries that bring leads, from analytics and Search Console, for one fixed date range.
    • Crawl the site and export every URL with its traffic, backlinks and conversions.
    • Mark the protect list, the pages that earn traffic, links or leads. Each one keeps its URL or gets a 301.
    • List what fails on the current site, such as slow templates, confusing navigation or forms nobody completes.

    Critical: Take the baseline before anyone touches the site, and write the date on it. A baseline pulled after launch mixes old and new traffic and proves nothing.

    Done when: A dated baseline, a full URL inventory and a protect list.

  2. 2

    Set goals, scope and one approver

    Project lead and client approver

    Without a goal, a redesign ends as a matter of taste.

    GoalEveryone agrees what the redesign must change, what it will not touch and who decides.

    • Write two or three goals tied to the baseline, each with a measure and a review date.
    • Name the main audiences and the task each one must complete on the new site.
    • Review three competitor sites and note what to borrow and what to avoid.
    • List the platform, integrations and features the new site needs, and write down what is out of scope.
    • Name the stakeholders who give feedback and the one person who approves.

    Critical: Name one approver now, and give new ideas a phase two list instead of a place in this project. Redesigns stall when several people can say no and nobody can say yes.

    Writing the scope down in detail? Use the website requirements document template.

    Done when: Written goals with measures, a scope with exclusions and a named approver.

  3. 3

    Plan the structure, content and redirects

    Content lead and SEO lead

    Decide what happens to every old URL before design starts.

    GoalA new sitemap, a decision for every old URL and an owner for every piece of content.

    • Decide keep, rewrite, merge or remove for every URL in the inventory.
    • Draft the new sitemap and map each old URL that moves to its new address as a 301.
    • Give every page of new copy and imagery an owner and a due date.
    • Note the query each protect-list page ranks for, so the rewrite keeps the words that earn the ranking.

    Critical: Ask for content before design starts. Layouts drawn around placeholder text break when the real copy arrives.

    Done when: An approved sitemap, a redirect map covering every moved URL and a content plan with owners.

  4. 4

    Design and approve the templates

    Designer and client approver

    Approve templates, not just a homepage.

    GoalThe approver has signed off every key template on mobile and desktop before build starts.

    • Design the templates the site repeats, such as home, service, article and contact, with real content.
    • Show mobile and desktop for each template, including menus, form errors and empty states.
    • Check contrast, focus states and text size against WCAG 2.2 AA while changes are still cheap.
    • Run one design review round with a deadline, then record the approver's sign-off.

    Critical: Get the design approved in writing before build starts. A change after build means changing a template and every page that uses it.

    Done when: Written approval of every key template, on mobile and desktop.

  5. 5

    Build on staging and run the client review

    Developer and project lead

    Clients review what they can click.

    GoalThe approver and stakeholders have reviewed the working build, and every comment is resolved.

    • Build on a staging site that search engines cannot index, behind a password or a noindex rule.
    • Move the content in and reinstall analytics, tag manager, pixels and chat scripts from the old site.
    • Send reviewers the staging link with a deadline 48 to 72 hours out, and say that silence counts as approval.
    • Collect feedback as comments pinned to the page, one issue per comment, and resolve each one as fixed or answered.

    Critical: Mockups hide what clients notice on a working site, like slow pages, odd breaks on their own phone and copy that runs long. Review the build itself, or the real review happens after launch, in public.

    Recommended toolSimple Commenter

    Clients comment on the staging site from a link, without creating an account, and each comment carries a screenshot and browser details. It also takes PDF and image mockups, so the design round in step four can run in the same place. Any tool works here as long as comments are pinned to the page and tracked.

    Running the round in detail? Use the staging site client review checklist.

    Done when: A reviewed staging build with zero open comments and the approver's go.

  6. 6

    Test QA, speed and SEO before launch

    Developer and SEO lead

    A redirect map in a spreadsheet protects nothing.

    GoalThe new site works, is no slower than the old one and keeps what the old site earned in search.

    • Test the main flows and every form on the browsers and devices your analytics show, failure paths included.
    • Test every 301 in the redirect map, and crawl staging for broken links, missing titles and wrong canonicals.
    • Compare load times on key pages with the baseline. The new site should not be slower than the old one.
    • Check that each protect-list page kept its target query in the title, the heading and the copy.

    Critical: Test the redirects twice, on staging and again on production. Each old URL should land on its new page in one hop, not through a chain and not on the homepage.

    Running the full test pass? Use the website QA checklist.

    Done when: Clean QA results, every redirect tested and key pages at least as fast as the baseline.

  7. 7

    Launch, then measure against the baseline

    Project lead and developer

    The redesign is done when the numbers say so.

    GoalThe new site is live, watched and compared with the baseline on fixed dates.

    • Back up the old site, write the rollback steps and launch with the launch checklist.
    • Submit the new sitemap in Search Console and check the coverage and 404 reports daily for the first two weeks.
    • Compare traffic, conversions and rankings with the baseline at 30 and 90 days, using date ranges of the same length.
    • Hold a short retro with the client, then move the phase two list into the next plan.

    Critical: Rankings can move for a few weeks while search engines crawl the new URLs. Judge the redesign on the 90-day comparison, and look into any protect-list page that lost its position.

    Planning launch day itself? Use the website launch checklist.

    Done when: A live site, a 90-day comparison with the baseline shared with the approver, and a phase two list.

The checklist is tool-agnostic on purpose. Step five recommends Simple Commenter because client review is the step we build for.

The checklist is process guidance, not legal advice.

The baseline sheet

Measure before, then twice after. Copy this table into a spreadsheet on the baseline date, and fill in the last two columns at 30 and 90 days, using date ranges of the same length each time.

What to recordWhere to find itBaseline+30 days+90 days
Sessions to key pagesAnalytics
Conversions or leadsAnalytics or CRM
Top landing pagesAnalytics
Queries that bring leads, with positionsSearch Console
Pages with backlinksSearch Console links report or a backlink tool
Load time on key templatesPageSpeed Insights

Write the scope down with the website requirements document template, set the dates with the website project plan template, and use the website launch checklist when the approved build is ready to ship.

Trusted by 600+ agencies, freelancers, and enterprises

Trusted by Agencies,
Loved by Clients

See why web professionals call Simple Commenter the best website feedback tool, and never look back.

/ Rated 5.0 on Product Hunt & 4.8 on G2

Simple. Effective. Game Changer

@Dsouldiva

Finally, a feedback tool my clients actually enjoy

@craigfenton

A Game-Changer for Web Feedback – Worth Every Penny!

@ryanbarilla

The tool I've been searching for

@alexs89

Simple, yet ingenious

@koen.kerkvliet

Great feedback app and so easy to use!

@iamvictor

Hidden Gem

@greg319

Fantastic tool for working with clients

@devdbydesign

An Essential Tool for Enhancing Communication with Clients

@Fiorenzomi

Great product!

@gramir

Very useful product and excellent support

@Ulrich86098

Simple Commenter has changed the way I work

@Jim Langman

Deserves +1000 tacos

@IgnacioJadue

Clients LOVED using Simple Commenter

@Katelyn

Phantastic

@user6961b

They fixed my issue in literal seconds from emailing them

@100587018771155070259

Super handy tool. The developer is very responsive.

@neposeda

I didn't realize how much I needed this tool!

@koen.kerkvliet

Life changed in under 5 minutes

@Dsouldiva

My clients have been engaged like never before

@Jim Langman

Simple. Effective. Game Changer

@Dsouldiva

Finally, a feedback tool my clients actually enjoy

@craigfenton

A Game-Changer for Web Feedback – Worth Every Penny!

@ryanbarilla

The tool I've been searching for

@alexs89

Simple, yet ingenious

@koen.kerkvliet

Great feedback app and so easy to use!

@iamvictor

Hidden Gem

@greg319

Fantastic tool for working with clients

@devdbydesign

An Essential Tool for Enhancing Communication with Clients

@Fiorenzomi

Great product!

@gramir

Very useful product and excellent support

@Ulrich86098

Simple Commenter has changed the way I work

@Jim Langman

Deserves +1000 tacos

@IgnacioJadue

Clients LOVED using Simple Commenter

@Katelyn

Phantastic

@user6961b

They fixed my issue in literal seconds from emailing them

@100587018771155070259

Super handy tool. The developer is very responsive.

@neposeda

I didn't realize how much I needed this tool!

@koen.kerkvliet

Life changed in under 5 minutes

@Dsouldiva

My clients have been engaged like never before

@Jim Langman

FAQ

Questions people ask before they try it

Something missing? Email info@simplecommenter.com and you’ll get an answer from the person who built it.

What is a website redesign checklist?
A website redesign checklist is an ordered list of the work that turns an existing site into a new one without losing what the old site earned. This one has seven steps. It starts with a dated baseline of the old site and ends with a comparison against that baseline after launch, and every step has an owner and a done condition.
How do you keep SEO rankings during a website redesign?
Record traffic, rankings and backlinks for each URL before you start, and keep the URLs of the pages that earn them wherever you can. Map every URL that moves to its new address with a 301, test each redirect on staging and on production, and keep each page's target query in the rewritten copy. After launch, watch the Search Console coverage and 404 reports and compare with the baseline at 30 and 90 days.
How long does a website redesign take?
It depends on page count, content readiness, integrations and how fast approvals come back, so set the date after the content plan exists, not before. Leave time for two review rounds, one on the design and one on the staging build, plus a retest window after fixes. If the client writes the copy, schedule from their content due date.
When is it time to redesign a website?
When the current site gets in the way of your goals. Common signs are a site that fails on phones, a CMS your team avoids editing, a brand that has moved on, or conversions falling while traffic holds steady. If only the look is the problem and the structure still works, a refresh is the smaller job.
What is the difference between a website redesign and a refresh?
A refresh changes the look and the copy on the same structure and URLs. A redesign changes the structure and templates, and often the URLs or the CMS. A refresh can skip the redirect map and most of step three, but it still needs the baseline, the client review on staging and the comparison after launch.
How is a redesign checklist different from a launch checklist?
The redesign checklist covers the whole project, from measuring the old site to comparing results after launch. The launch checklist covers only the days around go-live, such as removing noindex, DNS, SSL and the rollback plan. Use the redesign checklist to run the project and the launch checklist for step seven.
Is this website redesign checklist free?
Yes. Use it on this page, copy it as Markdown, or download the .docx and import it into Google Docs, Notion or your project wiki. No email or signup required. Step five recommends Simple Commenter, which has a 14-day free trial with no credit card.

Run the redesign review on the page itself

Use the checklist for the whole project. When the staging build is ready, Simple Commenter lets clients pin comments to the page without an account, and your team works through them in one dashboard. Try it free for 14 days, no credit card needed.

No credit card required.

Plan the dates with the website project plan template, test with the website QA checklist, or ship with the website launch checklist.